I have never before eliminated a book before completion. This was not good writing and really just a verbal porn activity. Looked for the plot. Ugh.

I love this book so much !!

One of the few book I've read in a while that I actually wouldn't mind reading again. Hands down one of the best from Hoover. Excellent Finish and resolve and characters you can't help but love.

Loved this book! My one criticism of the narration is the way Deacon Lee said “Rachel”. It drove me WILD and almost made me turn it off to be honest. The enunciation sounded unnatural, and overall I thought the narration made the character sound immature.

Great book!

Really enjoyed this read

Kept my interest and I shed a tear at the end. Well done!

Was hard to finish. Tate and Miles are annoying. I tried to like it. I also couldn’t stand miles’s narratator say the word Rachel one more time in a row. I guess anything sucks after reading “reminders of you”. Two stars because I love coho so much. But really I’d like to give it just 1.

trauma with a side of romanticizing an emotionally abusive relationship

Omg, the worst book ever. I lost credit for this

This book was ok. A lot better toward the end. The middle was verbal porn and the narrator for Colin was extremely annoying to listen to.

It was good. Different storyline. Wasn’t not a fan of Miles’ narration and Rachel Rachel Rachel…

The narration of this book was beautiful! The story was good and the narration was great. It would be a good first listen.

This book made me fall in love with reading again

Like this book I can’t explain with words how perfect this book is, read nowwwee

Very entertaining and fun to listen to. I gave it a 4 star because I thought that the story was a little predictable, although I enjoyed the ending. I also had a hard time with Miles Voice reader. But all in all a fun read that I really enjoyed!

I really liked the female narrator but the male voice made me cringe at times.

Absolutely loved this book from beginning to end.

Not for me. the story was good, but I absolutely could not relate to the characters. maybe it's because it was audio and not in my own mind.

I loved this book. Heartfelt all the way.

a good read. one I'd definitely reread again and again.

A very nice write-up

I liked this book a lot but was not a fan of the narrators.

i loved this book colleen Hoover's books are just amazing and ugly love made me cry,laugh .

I really enjoyed Verity, so maybe my expectations were too high. The plot was engaging, but I'm always turned off by excessive sex scenes. The end was predictable. Narration was great, or I would have given only 2 stars

Wow! Very interesting

this book is great.

Good

This book…oh hot lanta…Mr. Miles is all I can say! This book was good, a top contender in what Colleen Hoover books I have read so far!!

Heart wrenching and beautiful

One of my faves from Col Hoover. Quite naughty too!

I couldn’t even get through the whole ass story.

Beautifully narrated

Conlleven Hoover gran escritora te explica estas en vivo un gran libro

Absolutely loved this book!

Couldn’t put it down

Worth a listen, good book

Really disliked the voice of both narrators. The female sounded so bland. The male narrator was more painful. He sounded so insanely creepy/cringey. This was an audiobook I severely wish I read in my own head bc the voices really took away. Amazing book otherwise, I loved it. Absolutely loved the ending p

The narrator!! Rachel, Rachel Rachel Rachel .. then Lisa Lisa argh.. I was laughing then annoyed.

Great book couldn’t put it down.

Better than it end with us...

Why did miles narrator say “Rachel” so weird! I couldn’t stop cringing

Best Colleen Hoover book I have read thus far!

The male narrator's voice was not at all what it should have been. Definitely took away from the experience, and I wish I would have read it instead of listening to it. The voice of the narrator was weak in comparison to the description. Both characters were desperate, and the repeat of "favorite words" was getting annoying.

I really liked this book. It was funny, at some points, made me chuckle. It held my interest. Love is ugly, and breathtaking, and frustrating, and makes you feel like you are on top of the world. At least for a little while.

I liked the book overall. Female narrator was good but the male narrator ruined the character for me. He sounded like the male character from the Netflix series, “You,” which just made him creepy. I imagine it would have been better if I had read the paperback version.

OMG- the writing here was a mix between great, scintillating porn or sappy "make me want to throw up". And how Miles as a narrator said "Rachel?"- I can't believe I listened to almost all of it- but I did! Would not recommend.

It was okay I suppose.

Such a good book I totally recommend

The book was amazing! But I did not like the male narrators voice. It just did not fit.

Just cringe.. didn’t mind other Colleen Hoover but couldn’t even get half way through this one without giving up. Also character descriptions/ thought patterns in the book was almost the same as her previous books (even though the titles are unrelated)

Readers were excellent, the story itself was great but not perfect, a little predictable.

I love

Captivating story! Ending had me in happy tears. Romance is not my go to but this was great!

I tried this book as there are many Colleen Hoover novels around currently. Battled on to chapter 11 but the tedium got the better of me. Absolute banality! Life is too short to waste on bad novels.

really liked the story but hated the "male voice" narration

excellent !!

Terrible book, couldn’t get past the first few chapters

Male narrator made it difficult to listen to, almost gave up on the book but glad I stuck with it

Great book! Beautiful story!

very good book. had me on my toes the whole time

I rarely put a book aside before getting all the way through, but this one was really rather rough to listen to. After two hours, I could take no more! The story could have been good but the writing…. Awful! A scene that could have been conveyed in a powerful sentence or two, is dragged on and on with simple, repetitive words. And the narration is almost as bad. The male cadence is flat and clipped. Absolutely no emotion.

Interesting read. I wouldn’t recommend it to people who aren’t into erotic romance novels though.

The narrators make it hard to picture the characters. They sound and speak alot older than the characters so it’s not believable. It makes it difficult to enjoy. I can’t STAND how Miles say RAY-CHULL.

Sex, more sex, boring sea. Plot is thin.

I loved this book. I felt that she put words to some of the loneliness I have felt after love and not wanting to love. I really liked the book.

Was trying to read it on my own. It started way too slow for me ended up just finishing it on the audiobook and it’s a good book just prefer listening to the audio then reading it by myself.

Too porn-y, but good background read.

One of my favorites by Colleen Hoover (next to Verity)!

Not my favorite Colleen Hoover book..The narrator Deacon Lee was really hard to listen to, did not fit the character at all, and made the story very cringey. Storyline was a bit predictable and the "love" scenes were getting really old and made up 75% of the book, which screams cheap thrills.

LOVEEEDD! Literally one of my favorite books by colleen <3

Really liked the book but thought I would lose my mind if he said “Rachel” one more time. Other then that great!

Not for me. Not much of a romance novel kind of woman, so that’s not too surprising. What I thought was almost cringe worthy was listening to the narrator who played miles as a kid make that weird “teenager” voice. It was just weird to be an adult listening to what is supposed to be two teenagers have sex. Just made me cringe.

Great book to listen to while going for a hot girl walk. A little predictable but still a great listen.

I truly love books by this author. They are always so well written & moving. My only complaint…and it’s a big one…is the raunchy sex scenes. I wish she would tone it down some. Raunchy

colleen is such a great author and the narrators did an amazing job of capturing the words and moments written

Disappointing. I wanted to like this book, but can’t. Plot too predictable and moralistic.

The repetitiveness in using names in situations and the unnecessary drooling details kept me from finishing this.

Great book didn’t care for the male narrators voice so much but great book none the less.

Tate is a very unlikeable character. She is a weak woman who no one reading this would want to relate to. The only interesting parts are the flashbacks to when Miles is younger. First Colleen Hoover I haven’t enjoyed.

Miles' narrator is unboreable. Kind of creepy step sibling situation. I don't think I will finish this book.

Great book. I was a little nervous with some of the reviews but definitely worth the listen.

Well that was time I’ll never get back. Predictable and poorly written. Amateurish. Awful.

This book is okay, a little cliche, but the dialogue is SO BAD. It's full of cringy, repetitive sentences that are over dramatized and read like a YA smut novel. What could have been a promising plot was substituted for an overdone "lovemaking conquers all problems" trope. This book isn't all bad, the female narrator is pretty good, but overall this is book is a stretch on reality. The male narrator's voice is really annoying as well.

Loved it! Another winner from Colleen Hoover!

Mile's voice was hard to listen to.

The male narrator was very hard to listen to.

This book is great, cried so hard, but it was so good!

Great ending

I loved it so much!!! I did laugh a lot throughout this book!! Beautiful book with some very sad moments.

Loved it! I did not like Miles voice, in the beginning, maybe that's the point, but I have grown to love it... Tate's voice is... amazing from start to finish.

The book was a recommendation from a YouTube Influencer, I am so glad I gave it a try because I loved Miles & Tate's story. This was my first novel that I had read from Colleen Hoover but I look forward to reading more.

Loved it!

Amazing and heart breaking book.

this is my new favorite book

This book always had me wondering what next and the characters kept it interesting with a heartbreaking romantic twist. I cannot lie ... a few tears were shed.

I love the book but can't stand Miles voice. I wanted him to sound different. Colleen Hoover never disappoints!

I will NEVER forget how the author pronounced the name "Rachel" every time. I hate that name now with a passion. Nice read though, 3.5 stars! Was pretty depressing that's why I rated it so low, however it did teach me a few things about the good parts of love and also the very bad parts of it.

I'm a sucker for romance and this is the first time I read anything by Colleen Hoover and I loved it. It was so heart wrenching and lovely all at the same time. Not a typical boy meets girl love story but something a lot deeper.. The heartbreak miles goes through at such a young age, and never really gets over. The narrator for tate was good but miles narrator did come across annoying and emotionless. However would recommend this to anyone and everyone.

I was very hesitant to get this book because the reviews on Goodreads weren't that great. However, my cousin read this book and really likes the author so I took a chance and downloaded the book. I actually really liked it. In fact I listened to it twice! Guess I'm just a sap for love stories, sad, happy... I'll read it. I'm also excited to learn that it's becoming a movie. I truly hope Miles is portrayed well because he's a complicated character. Loved the narrator as well, she made me love Tate.