I couldn't stop listening once I'd started. I liked Grace and her motley crew and would be interested in hearing more about their exploits. The author touched on important social and human issues that we are all familiar with: poverty, abuse, addiction, loss, jealousy to name a few. I particularly enjoyed the setting by the bracing Scottish sea and Harvey. Having a chocolate-coloured retriever mix, I smiled, recognising so many of his antics as familiar. The narrator was great!

It was a great book. It would make a very good movie.

Loved it! I enjoyed the views of the sea, the paranormal storyline

great book! hard to put down (stop listening) Loved the twists.narrator was fantastic and had a soothing voice.

Really good! Narrator is great!!

Enjoyed and would recommend.

Good book and storyline with a great narrator. Smooth like butter

An amazing story with an awesome ending!

if the main character was a former police inspector then I must be a member of the SAS with a grizzly bear as a pet not a large dog who it seems is her reason for living a very pathetic woman amid a decent but long winded story largely spent talking about her dog!

Great twists, not an easy guess to the resolution. Great ending! Narrator did well, I’d follow her.

This was just meh for me. Felt like it dragged a bit. Classic who dunnit but surprise at the end that I did t see coming.

Really enjoyed this book. The ending was great and unexpected. Will be looking for more from this author to listen to.

easy listening, interesting, surprising ending

Really enjoyed book, only wish they went a little further at the end.

Wow! The ending was quite compelling. Good story. Enjoyed this book- would recommend it.

Great read! Although I could tell from the start who the 'bad guy' was going to be...

Lovely story. A very easy listen while driving across country.

I really enjoyed it. I’ve already purchased the next one in the series.

Lovely story that kept you interested.

I really enjoyed this book. Kept me interested all the way through and the narration was excellent .

wonderful!

Great “who done it!” Very layered and complex, and very engaging. Narrator is great as well.

Loved this book it had so many different twists and turns I couldn't stop listening.

Not into paranormal books

One twist I didn’t see coming, but made sense and a second twist that I saw coming, but was “feel good” satisfying. It’s a little bit heavy feeling. There isn’t much relief from dark themes that run through the book, such as suicide; however, the final message of the book is hopeful, the characters are very believable and the mystery is well conceived. The narrator is not inspired, but good; although, her accent sounds more Irish than Scottish. It is a good voice to represent the book’s heroine. Also, I very much like the heroine’s relationship with her dog, Harvey. Overall, a very satisfying read.

Kept me intrigued.good listeninggood author

this was good and the narrator did a great job!

Kept me interested. I liked the pace. Good one for commute.

Enjoyed it a lot.

As a serial listener it took me a bit of time to get accustomed to a new set of characters and place. But I liked the people and the story which of course wove personal agendas with the ‘case.’ All in all it was very enjoyable. Yet aI need to say the very ending was so good, I wouldn’t have minded if there was a book two!

This was an absolutely entertaining story, such that I’ll be looking for the others by this author. It wasn’t an obvious mystery so it really grabs the reader and doesn’ty let go until the very end which closes on a beautiful poignant note with one sentence. Wrapped up neatly in a bow. Delightful!!

Very good recording. I couldn't wait to get back in my car to hear more of the story. Very good narrator. Such a surprising ending. I thought I had figured it all out. I was wrong.

Pretty good book, but as I listened over a couple of trips, I kind of had trouble keeping track of the cast of characters. Probably more my fault than the authors. Really enjoyed the reader.

I usually firce myself through a book butthis one I just can't do it. This book moves way to slow for a mystery. Way to much back story and environmental details that are totally not necessary for the story. The narrator is also very monotone and does nothing to captivate attention.

Loved it!

Quite enjoyable, easy reading/listening.

Entertaining mystery. Easy to follow. Narrator good.

A little predictable.

My first Cozy Mystery and I think I'm hooked!

I really enjoyed this book. Good plot twists. Kept my interest and that's hard to do.

Loved the characters . Can’t wait for the next book.

Great story, can’t wait for the 2nd one. Left ya hanging

Loved this book! I look forward to reading more about Grace and her coworkers in the next book.

I enjoyed this book! Lots of twists and turns. I listened to it nearly all in 1 day.

I enjoyed this book. Good plot with lots of twists. Loved the setting and the characters too. Looking forward to the next book.

An absolutely superb listen. I found my walks getting longer and longer, couldn’t turn it off. And what a smashing narrator, absolutely brilliant job on all the characters voices. Bravo to both author and reader.

Loved it! Very interesting

Very entertaining! I enjoyed it right from the beginning!

Excellent, couldn't stop listening. Narrator was very good.

Never could get in to this one.